Use the same evaluation task for every candidate
Provide a product, market, buyer stage and a public source the agency may inspect. Ask each team to identify a real information gap, justify its next step, and show a redacted example of how it records its work.
| Industry | Ask the agency to assess | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Machinery manufacturing | How would a buyer check application fit before speaking to engineering? | A requirements-to-URL map, exact specifications or limitations, engineering sign-off and a qualified inquiry definition. |
| Consumer goods | How would a buyer compare two products with similar names but different availability? | A product and variant source check, ownership of approved product facts and separate measures for visibility, clicks and conversion. |
| US home and renovation | How would a buyer verify installation and compatibility before purchase? | Sources for regional availability, compatibility and instructions, with a market-specific panel and a stated basis for assisted outcomes. |
Score the evidence from explanation to repeatability
Assess industry understanding, source accuracy, implementation ownership and measurement on the same scale. Require a named owner for publishing and access to the agreed exports before final selection.
| Level | Evidence the agency can show |
|---|---|
| 0 · Unsupported | The team cannot show a relevant record or explain how it would verify a claim. |
| 1 · Method and sample | The team can explain the buyer decision and show a usable example of its method. |
| 2 · Verified implementation | A dated record shows the actual action, responsible party and an observable verification. |
| 3 · Repeatable industry practice | Comparable projects show repeated checks with documented coverage, definitions and decisions informed by the results. |
Turn the shortlist into comparable proposals
Ask the people assigned to your project to walk through the sample. Write unanswered questions into the RFQ as explicit scope or acceptance items, then compare the same outputs and responsibilities across quotes.